| Name | Birth date | Relationship with Elizabeth Metcalf |
|---|
| Metcalf, William | 1764 | Brother |
| Metcalf, William | December 24, 1774 | 1st cousin |
| Metcalf, William Aj. | January 16, 1828 | Grandnephew |
| Metcalf, William Asa | December 25, 1903 | 2nd great-grandnephew |
| Metcalf, William Ashley | 1863 | Great-grandnephew |
| Metcalf, William D. | 1788 | Nephew |
| Metcalf, William Henry | 1847 | Great-grandnephew |
| Metcalf, William Howard | November 11, 1934 | 3rd great-grandnephew |
| Metcalf, Zachary | | 5th great-grandnephew |
| Miller, Ophelia Juanita | August 18, 1935 | Wife of the 2nd great-grandnephew |
| Morris, Lee | | Husband of the 3rd great-grandniece |
| Norris, Mary Polly | February 16, 1717/18 | Grandmother |
| Polly | Abt. 1735 | Mother |
| Prather, Byron | | 4th great-grandnephew |
| Prather, Byron Jack | | Husband of the 3rd great-grandniece |
| Prather, Richard (Rickey) | | 4th great-grandnephew |
| Prather, Todd | | 4th great-grandnephew |
| Pybus, Paul | | 4th great-grandnephew |
| Pybus, Ray | | 4th great-grandnephew |
| Pybus, Renae | | 4th great-grandniece |
| Pybus, Theophilus (Dock) | | Husband of the 3rd great-grandniece |
| Raines, Clarence Turman | | Husband of the 3rd great-grandniece |
| Raines, Julia Ann | | 4th great-grandniece |
| Raines, Phillip | | 4th great-grandnephew |
| Raines, Scott | | 4th great-grandnephew |
| Sharpe, Jason | | Husband of the 4th great-grandniece |
| Skipper, Bradley Wade | October 08, 1968 | 4th great-grandnephew |
| Skipper, Rebecka Leopal | April 17, 1997 | 5th great-grandniece |
| Skipper, Samantha Anne | September 19, 2000 | 5th great-grandniece |
| Skipper, William A. | | Husband of the 3rd great-grandniece |
| Skipper, William Paul | May 08, 1964 | 4th great-grandnephew |
| Smith, Laura Ann | | Wife of the grandnephew |
| Smith, Maude Evelyn | April 22, 1909 | Wife of the 2nd great-grandnephew |
| Sr., John Metcalf | 1680 | Great-grandfather |
| Stokes, Rudolph | | Husband of the 3rd great-grandniece |
| Tharpe, Annie Ruth | | Wife of the 2nd great-grandnephew |
| Tharpe, Debra Kay | | 4th great-grandniece |
| Tharpe, Kevin | | 4th great-grandnephew |
| Tharpe, Travis | | Husband of the 3rd great-grandniece |
| Trawick, Jeremy | | Husband of the 4th great-grandniece |
| Tripplet, Jeramy | | Husband of the 4th great-grandniece |
| Watford, Katford | | Wife of the 3rd great-grandnephew |
| White, George | Abt. 1780 | Brother-in-law |
| White, Kayra | | 5th great-grandniece |
| White, Keith | | Husband of the 4th great-grandniece |
| Wills, Chase Even | August 08, 2000 | 5th great-grandnephew |
| Woodham, Inez | | Wife of the 2nd great-grandnephew |