| Name | Birth date | Relationship with John Cotton |
|---|
| (), Elizabeth | | 14th great-grandmother |
| (Feiner), Alice | | 1st cousin once removed of the wife |
| (Feiner), Ingrid | | 2nd cousin of the wife |
| 1st, Lambert | Unknown | 28th great-grandfather |
| 1st, Louis | | 31st great-grandfather |
| 2nd, Lambert | | 27th great-grandfather |
| 2nd, Louis | | 30th great-grandfather |
| 2nd, William | | 23rd great-grandfather |
| 3rd, William | | 22nd great-grandfather |
| 4th, Henry | Unknown | 26th great-grandfather |
| 4th, Louis | | 29th great-grandfather |
| Abbe, Hannah | September 30, 1824 | 2nd great-grandmother |
| Abbe, Harris | November 30, 1790 | 3rd great-grandfather |
| Adela | Unknown | 26th great-grandmother |
| Adelicia | | 24th great-grandmother |
| Alfred | Unknown | 26th great-grandfather |
| Ardenne, Godrigo of | | 30th great-grandfather |
| Baker, Cynthia | Unknown | 1st cousin 5 times removed |
| Baker, Jeremiah | Unknown | 1st cousin 5 times removed |
| | | Husband of the 3rd great-grandaunt |
| Bartelt, Jean | | 2nd cousin of the wife |
| Bartelt, Marian | | 1st cousin once removed of the wife |
| Beddome, Emerson | April 24, 1990 | Nephew of the wife |
| Bellows, Mary Catherine | Unknown | Great-grandaunt |
| Beth, Mary | | Wife of the 1st cousin once removed |
| Blish, child10 | | Grandaunt of the wife |
| Blish, child4 | | Grandaunt of the wife |
| Blish, child5 | | Grandaunt of the wife |
| Blish, child6 | | Grandaunt of the wife |
| Blish, child7 | | Grandaunt of the wife |
| Blish, child8 | | Grandaunt of the wife |
| Blish, child9 | | Grandaunt of the wife |
| Blish, Cornelius V. | July 20, 1826 | Great-grandfather of the wife |
| Blish, Edward | 1854 | Granduncle of the wife |
| Blish, George Arthur | July 18, 1870 | Grandfather of the wife |
| Blish, Hazel Lucille | December 18, 1924 | Mother-in-law |
| Blish, John | 1866 | Granduncle of the wife |
| Blish, Neil | 1907 | Uncle of the wife |
| Bonnie | | 29th great-grandmother |
| Boughner, Duncan | Unknown | Husband of the grandaunt |
| Boughner, Duncan | Unknown | 1st cousin once removed |
| Boughner, Helen | Unknown | 1st cousin once removed |
| Boughner, Mary | Unknown | 1st cousin once removed |
| Boughner, Rachael | Unknown | 1st cousin once removed |
| Boughner, Topsy () | Unknown | Wife of the 1st cousin once removed |
| Boy | Unknown | Granduncle of the wife |
| Brogan, Adelia | 1857 | Great-grandmother of the wife |
| Burns, James | Unknown | Husband of the great-grandaunt |
| Buzzard, Rick | June 4, 1955 | Brother-in-law |
| Calvert, Resia | Unknown | Husband of the 2nd great-grandaunt |
