| Name | Birth date | Relationship with John Cotton |
|---|
| Reade, Elizabeth () | Unknown | 10th great-grandmother |
| Reade, Margaret | Unknown | 9th great-grandmother |
| Rendler, Julia | | Grandaunt of the wife |
| Roberts, Hannah | Unknown | 4th great-grandmother |
| Robertson, Charles H. | June 5, 1946 | Brother-in-law |
| Saltz, Joe | Unknown | Husband of the 1st cousin once removed |
| Senne, George | Unknown | Husband of the aunt |
| Snyder, David | Unknown | Husband of the 2nd great-grandaunt |
| Sr., Henry Stephens | Unknown | 7th great-grandfather |
| Sr., Jeremiah Baker | 1747 | Husband of the 4th great-grandaunt |
| St Hilliario, Maude | | 23rd great-grandmother |
| Staller, Caleb | Unknown | 1st cousin once removed |
| Staller, Joshua | Unknown | 1st cousin once removed |
| Staller, Kerry | Unknown | Husband of the 1st cousin |
| Staller, Nathaniel | Unknown | 1st cousin once removed |
| Staller, Rueben | Unknown | 1st cousin once removed |
| Staller, Simeon | Unknown | 1st cousin once removed |
| Stephens, Anne | Unknown | 4th great-grandaunt |
| Stephens, Henry | November 20, 1681 | 6th great-grandfather |
| Stephens, Hila | Unknown | 3rd great-grandaunt |
| | | Wife of the 1st cousin 5 times removed |
| Stephens, Jedediah | August 12, 1716 | 5th great-grandfather |
| Stephens, Jedediah | May 11, 1751 | 4th great-grandfather |
| Stephens, Joshua | 1793 | 4th great-granduncle |
| Stephens, Joshua Chapman | May 30, 1816 | 2nd great-grandfather |
| Stephens, Mary M. | Unknown | Great-grandaunt |
| Stephens, Nathan | December 8, 1773 | 3rd great-grandfather |
| Stephens, Rachael Jane | March 25, 1855 | Great-grandmother |
| Stephens, Rhoda () | Unknown | Wife of the 4th great-granduncle |
| Stephens, Rufus | Unknown | 4th great-granduncle |
| Stevens, Matthew | Unknown | Husband of the 2nd cousin 4 times removed |
| Stewart, Almeron | February 21, 1857 | Great-granduncle |
| Stewart, Fanetta B. | May 9, 1863 | Great-grandaunt |
| Stewart, Harold | Unknown | 1st cousin once removed |
| Stewart, Harry Joshua | September 14, 1876 | Granduncle |
| Stewart, Infant Boy | February 16, 1844 | Great-granduncle |
| Stewart, James | Unknown | 1st cousin once removed |
| Stewart, James Hall | March 4, 1853 | Great-grandfather |
| Stewart, John Melvin | March 8, 1847 | Great-granduncle |
| Stewart, Lorene | | 2nd cousin |
| Stewart, Lucretia | February 12, 1841 | Great-grandaunt |
| Stewart, Luther | August 7, 1842 | Great-granduncle |
| Stewart, Mable Emma | October 24, 1886 | Grandmother |
| Stewart, Matilda Elizabeth | February 23, 1845 | Great-grandaunt |
| Stewart, Melissa | November 16, 1839 | Great-grandaunt |
| Stewart, Olive Ada | June 27, 1860 | Great-grandaunt |
| Stewart, Otto K. | February 20, 1878 | Granduncle |
| Stewart, Otto K. | December 21, 1927 | 1st cousin once removed |
| Stewart, Pauline Adelaide | January 12, 1881 | Grandaunt |
| Stewart, Rachael | Unknown | 1st cousin once removed |
