| Name | Birth date | Relationship with John Cotton |
|---|
| Stewart, Samuel Edgar | January 23, 1849 | Great-granduncle |
| Stewart, Susan Jane | March 16, 1855 | Great-grandaunt |
| Stewart, Villa () | Unknown | Wife of the granduncle |
| Stewart, William | July 29, 1816 | 2nd great-grandfather |
| Stewart, William | Unknown | 1st cousin once removed |
| Stewart, William Ford | January 27, 1851 | Great-granduncle |
| Stewart, Winifred | Unknown | 1st cousin once removed |
| Stull, Henry | Unknown | Husband of the 2nd great-grandaunt |
| Swan, Maria | Unknown | Wife of the 2nd great-granduncle |
| Terzian, Alice | March 19, 1923 | Wife of the uncle |
| Thomas | | 2nd cousin |
| Twitteton, Harry | | 14th great-grandfather |
| Twitteton, Margaret | | 13th great-grandmother |
| Valentine, Alice | | Wife of the granduncle |
| Vickers, Ann Helen | September 13, 1938 | Wife of the uncle |
| Watkins, Agnes | Unknown | 11th great-grandmother |
| Whipple, Albert J. III | October 2, 1947 | 1st cousin |
| Whipple, Albert J., Jr. | August 6, 1921 | Husband of the aunt |
| Whipple, Christopher Michael | January 19, 1972 | 1st cousin once removed |
| Whipple, James Otto | February 28, 1950 | 1st cousin |
| Whipple, Jason Timothy | April 15, 1974 | 1st cousin once removed |
| Whipple, Jeffery Lee | September 22, 1958 | 1st cousin |
| Whipple, John Thomas | April 19, 1949 | 1st cousin |
| Wiggins, Clarissa | May 23, 1785 | 3rd great-grandmother |
| Withers, Nancy Delilah | November 17, 1846 | Great-grandmother |
| Withers, Samuel | Unknown | 4th great-grandfather |
| Withers, Thomas | Unknown | 2nd great-grandfather |
| Withers, Thomas | Unknown | 3rd great-grandfather |
