| Name | Relationship with John Gay | Civil | Canon |
|---|
| Addington, Unknown Male | Husband of the granddaughter | | |
| Anderson, Juanita | Wife of the great-grandson | | |
| Atkinson, Mary Alice | Daughter-in-law | | |
| Auctor, Eva Marie | Wife of the 2nd great-grandson | | |
| Bean, Dollie | Wife of the grandson | | |
| Benavidez, Manuel B. | Husband of the 2nd great-granddaughter | | |
| Bennett, George Ann Cluck | Spouse of the great-grandson | | |
| Bird, Joyce | Wife of the great-grandson | | |
| Bratcher, Virgie Lou | Wife of the grandson | | |
| Briggs, Gary Don | Husband of the great-granddaughter | | |
| Briggs, Randal | 2nd great-grandson | IV | 4 |
| Briggs, Ronald | 2nd great-grandson | IV | 4 |
| Broadstreet, Iva Belle | Great-granddaughter | III | 3 |
| Broadstreet, Joseph Frank | Great-grandson | III | 3 |
| Broadstreet, Lela Mae | Great-granddaughter | III | 3 |
| Broadstreet, Mary Etta | Great-granddaughter | III | 3 |
| Broadstreet, Mary Jo | 2nd great-granddaughter | IV | 4 |
| Broadstreet, William F. | Husband of the granddaughter | | |
| Burns, Lillian Mae | Great-granddaughter | III | 3 |
| Burns, Unknown | Husband of the granddaughter | | |
| Christenson, Andy J. | Husband of the great-granddaughter | | |
| Christopher, Alma Charlottie | Wife of the grandson | | |
| Cook, Elma | 2nd great-granddaughter | IV | 4 |
| Cook, Floyd | Husband of the great-granddaughter | | |
| Cook, Floyd Lee | 2nd great-grandson | IV | 4 |
| Crites, Clay Wesley | 3rd great-grandson | V | 5 |
| Crites, John Wesley | Husband of the great-granddaughter | | |
| Crites, John Wesley II | 2nd great-grandson | IV | 4 |
| Crites, John Wesley III | 3rd great-grandson | V | 5 |
| Crites, Karen Sue | 2nd great-granddaughter | IV | 4 |
| Crites, Lesley Kent | 3rd great-grandson | V | 5 |
| Crites, Nancy Carroll | 2nd great-granddaughter | IV | 4 |
| Culp, Sarah | Wife of the grandson | | |
| Davenport, Jenny | Wife of the 2nd great-grandson | | |
| Dilfer, First Dau | 2nd great-granddaughter | IV | 4 |
| Dilfer, First Son | 2nd great-grandson | IV | 4 |
| Dilfer, Jack | Husband of the great-granddaughter | | |
| Dzenowski, Dean | Husband of the 3rd great-granddaughter | | |
| England, James B. | Husband of the 3rd great-granddaughter | | |
| Fahringer, Laura Lee | Wife of the 2nd great-grandson | | |
| Ferguson, Richard Franklin | Son-in-law | | |
| Fox, Donnie | 2nd great-grandson | IV | 4 |
| Fox, Paul | Husband of the great-granddaughter | | |
| Fox, Sue | 2nd great-granddaughter | IV | 4 |
| Frerichs, Delores Yvonne | Wife of the 2nd great-grandson | | |
| Fuller, James William | Husband of the 2nd great-granddaughter | | |
| Fuller, Shelia Raye | 3rd great-granddaughter | V | 5 |
| Gay, Albert | Great-grandson | III | 3 |
| Gay, Arthur | Grandson | II | 2 |
| Gay, Aubrey Leon | Great-grandson | III | 3 |
