| Name | Relationship with Thomas Marsteller | Civil | Canon |
| Marsteller, Alfred Emery | 1st cousin twice removed | VI | 4 |
| Marsteller, Alice Mary | 3rd cousin | VIII | 4 |
| Marsteller, Alonzo Dale | 3rd cousin once removed | IX | 5 |
| Marsteller, Alta May | 1st cousin twice removed | VI | 4 |
| Marsteller, Amy Jane | Niece | III | 2 |
| Marsteller, Andrew Jackson | Uncle | III | 2 |
| Marsteller, Anna | 2nd cousin once removed | VII | 4 |
| Marsteller, Anna Elizabeth | 3rd great-grandaunt | VII | 6 |
| Marsteller, Anna Jane | 1st cousin twice removed | VI | 4 |
| Marsteller, Anna Margaretha | 4th great-grandaunt | VIII | 7 |
| Marsteller, Arnold | 2nd cousin 4 times removed | X | 7 |
| Marsteller, Arthur | 1st cousin twice removed | VI | 4 |
| Marsteller, Arthur Richard | Brother | II | 1 |
| Marsteller, Arthur Richard | Nephew | III | 2 |
| Marsteller, Austin | Granduncle | IV | 3 |
| Marsteller, Austin Lawrence | 1st cousin twice removed | VI | 4 |
| Marsteller, Barbara | 2nd cousin 4 times removed | X | 7 |
| Marsteller, Barbara Jean | 2nd cousin once removed | VII | 4 |
| Marsteller, Belinda | 1st cousin 3 times removed | VII | 5 |
| Marsteller, Benjamim | 3rd great-grandfather | V | 5 |
| Marsteller, Benjamin Armstrong | 1st cousin 3 times removed | VII | 5 |
| Marsteller, Benjamin, Jr. | 2nd great-granduncle | VI | 5 |
| Marsteller, Bertha | 2nd cousin once removed | VII | 4 |
| Marsteller, Betty | 4th cousin | X | 5 |
| Marsteller, Beva Arlene | 3rd cousin | VIII | 4 |
| Marsteller, Bill | 3rd cousin once removed | IX | 5 |
| Marsteller, Bruce | 4th cousin | X | 5 |
| Marsteller, Burgess A. | 2nd cousin twice removed | VIII | 5 |
| Marsteller, Burton | 2nd cousin twice removed | VIII | 5 |
| Marsteller, Carl | 4th cousin | X | 5 |
| Marsteller, Carl A. | 2nd cousin once removed | VII | 4 |
| Marsteller, Carl Eugene | 2nd cousin once removed | VII | 4 |
| Marsteller, Carrie | Aunt | III | 2 |
| Marsteller, Catharine | 3rd great-grandaunt | VII | 6 |
| Marsteller, Cathleen Diane | 3rd cousin | VIII | 4 |
| Marsteller, Cecelia Marie | Niece | III | 2 |
| Marsteller, Cecil Alvin | 4th cousin | X | 5 |
| Marsteller, Charles | 2nd cousin once removed | VII | 4 |
| Marsteller, Charles | 4th cousin | X | 5 |
| Marsteller, Charles Burton | 1st cousin twice removed | VI | 4 |
| Marsteller, Charles Leroy | 1st cousin twice removed | VI | 4 |
| Marsteller, Charlotte | 1st cousin 3 times removed | VII | 5 |
| Marsteller, Clair J | 4th cousin | X | 5 |
| Marsteller, Clarence Eugene | 2nd cousin once removed | VII | 4 |
| Marsteller, Clarence R. | Uncle | III | 2 |
| Marsteller, Cledith | 3rd cousin once removed | IX | 5 |
| Marsteller, Cliff | 3rd cousin once removed | IX | 5 |
| Marsteller, Cloyd | 3rd cousin once removed | IX | 5 |
| Marsteller, Craig W. | 3rd cousin once removed | IX | 5 |
| Marsteller, Cramer | 2nd great-granduncle | VI | 5 |