| Name | Relationship with Thomas Marsteller | Civil | Canon |
| Marsteller, Glenn Foreman | 2nd cousin once removed | VII | 4 |
| Marsteller, Glenn Way | 1st cousin | IV | 2 |
| Marsteller, Glenn Way III | 1st cousin twice removed | VI | 4 |
| Marsteller, Glenn Way, Jr. | 1st cousin once removed | V | 3 |
| Marsteller, Gregory Norman | 3rd cousin | VIII | 4 |
| Marsteller, Hallie | 3rd cousin once removed | IX | 5 |
| Marsteller, Hannah | 3rd great-grandaunt | VII | 6 |
| Marsteller, Harold | 3rd cousin once removed | IX | 5 |
| Marsteller, Harold Emery | 2nd cousin once removed | VII | 4 |
| Marsteller, Harold Emery, Jr. | 3rd cousin | VIII | 4 |
| Marsteller, Harry Charles | 1st cousin once removed | V | 3 |
| Marsteller, Helen Elizabeth | 3rd cousin | VIII | 4 |
| Marsteller, Henderson | Granduncle | IV | 3 |
| Marsteller, Henry | 1st cousin 5 times removed | IX | 7 |
| Marsteller, Henry | 2nd cousin 4 times removed | X | 7 |
| Marsteller, Howard Edwin | 2nd cousin once removed | VII | 4 |
| Marsteller, Howard William | Brother | II | 1 |
| Marsteller, Inda Idell | 1st cousin twice removed | VI | 4 |
| Marsteller, Infant | 1st cousin 5 times removed | IX | 7 |
| Marsteller, Isabell | 2nd cousin once removed | VII | 4 |
| Marsteller, Jack | 4th cousin | X | 5 |
| Marsteller, Jackie Lynn | 1st cousin once removed | V | 3 |
| Marsteller, Jacob | 2nd great-granduncle | VI | 5 |
| Marsteller, James | 4th cousin once removed | XI | 6 |
| Marsteller, James | 2nd great-grandfather | IV | 4 |
| Marsteller, James Austin | 1st cousin twice removed | VI | 4 |
| Marsteller, James Edward | Brother | II | 1 |
| Marsteller, James Kenneth | 2nd cousin once removed | VII | 4 |
| Marsteller, James Murray | Great-granduncle | V | 4 |
| Marsteller, James Norman | 1st cousin twice removed | VI | 4 |
| Marsteller, James William | 2nd cousin once removed | VII | 4 |
| Marsteller, Jane | 4th cousin once removed | XI | 6 |
| Marsteller, Jane | 1st cousin 3 times removed | VII | 5 |
| Marsteller, Jay | 3rd cousin once removed | IX | 5 |
| Marsteller, Jennie | 1st cousin twice removed | VI | 4 |
| Marsteller, Jesse | 1st cousin 3 times removed | VII | 5 |
| Marsteller, Jesse Fayette | 2nd cousin twice removed | VIII | 5 |
| Marsteller, Jessie | 2nd great-granduncle | VI | 5 |
| Marsteller, Johann George | 4th great-grandfather | VI | 6 |
| Marsteller, Johann Heinrich | 4th great-granduncle | VIII | 7 |
| Marsteller, Johann Nickolaus | 4th great-granduncle | VIII | 7 |
| Marsteller, Johannes | 1st cousin 5 times removed | IX | 7 |
| Marsteller, Johannes | 3rd great-granduncle | VII | 6 |
| Marsteller, John | 2nd cousin 4 times removed | X | 7 |
| Marsteller, John | 2nd great-granduncle | VI | 5 |
| Marsteller, John | 3rd cousin 3 times removed | XI | 7 |
| Marsteller, John Daniel | 4th great-granduncle | VIII | 7 |
| Marsteller, John Ludwig | 1st cousin 5 times removed | IX | 7 |
| Marsteller, John Wesley | 3rd cousin once removed | IX | 5 |
| Marsteller, Jonathan | 1st cousin 5 times removed | IX | 7 |