| Name | Relationship with Peter Starr | Civil | Canon |
|---|
| Akley, Belinda Jean | Wife of the 4th great-grandson | | |
| Balestier, Bruce Charles | Husband of the 4th great-granddaughter | | |
| Blassengame, Robert | Husband of the 2nd great-granddaughter | | |
| Blassengame, Robert Allen | 3rd great-grandson | V | 5 |
| Borger, John | Son-in-law | | |
| Boyer, Dora | Great-granddaughter | III | 3 |
| Boyer, Frank | Husband of the granddaughter | | |
| Boyer, Harry | Great-grandson | III | 3 |
| Boyer, Roy | Great-grandson | III | 3 |
| Boyer, Victor | Great-grandson | III | 3 |
| Bradley, Edmund James | Ex-husband of the 3rd great-granddaughter | | |
| Bradley, Richard Edmund | 4th great-grandson | VI | 6 |
| Bush, Barbara | Wife of the grandson | | |
| Bush, James | Husband of the granddaughter | | |
| Bush, John Cardeus | Great-grandson | III | 3 |
| Bush, Zacharih | Great-grandson | III | 3 |
| Clarke, Susan Elaine | Wife of the 3rd great-grandson | | |
| Dietz | Husband of the granddaughter | | |
| Dillman, Catherine | Wife of the grandson | | |
| Dimarcello, Anna Sophia | 5th great-granddaughter | VII | 7 |
| Dimarcello, Christine Ann | 4th great-granddaughter | VI | 6 |
| Dimarcello, David Brian | 4th great-grandson | VI | 6 |
| Dimarcello, Elema Marie | 5th great-granddaughter | VII | 7 |
| Dimarcello, Frank Vincent | Husband of the 3rd great-granddaughter | | |
| Dimarcello, Michael Richard | 4th great-grandson | VI | 6 |
| Dunn, Jeffery D | 3rd great-grandson | V | 5 |
| Dunn, Jesse E | Husband of the 2nd great-granddaughter | | |
| Dunn, Nancy E | 3rd great-granddaughter | V | 5 |
| Dunn, Randall E | 3rd great-grandson | V | 5 |
| Dunn, Timothy E | 3rd great-grandson | V | 5 |
| Eifert, Lula Naomi | Wife of the great-grandson | | |
| Fiaring, Susanna | Wife of the grandson | | |
| Fishburn, Addison | 2nd great-grandson | IV | 4 |
| Fishburn, Irvin | 2nd great-grandson | IV | 4 |
| Fishburn, Steven | Husband of the great-granddaughter | | |
| Forester, Lois | Wife of the 2nd great-grandson | | |
| Fuchs, Marie Elizabeth | Wife | | |
| Gehres, Elizabeth | Wife of the grandson | | |
| Giltner, Alma Estella | 2nd great-granddaughter | IV | 4 |
| Giltner, Catherine Virgina | 2nd great-granddaughter | IV | 4 |
| Giltner, Charles Oscar | 2nd great-grandson | IV | 4 |
| Giltner, Dorothy Irene | 2nd great-granddaughter | IV | 4 |
| Giltner, John Abner | Husband of the great-granddaughter | | |
| Gutermann, Elizabeth Adams | 4th great-granddaughter | VI | 6 |
| Gutermann, Paul Eric | Husband of the 3rd great-granddaughter | | |
| Hale, Brian D | 3rd great-grandson | V | 5 |
| Hale, Brian L | 4th great-grandson | VI | 6 |
| Hale, Lawrence | Husband of the 2nd great-granddaughter | | |
| Hale, Marjorie J | 3rd great-granddaughter | V | 5 |
| Harnadek, Judith Ann | 3rd great-granddaughter | V | 5 |