| Name | Relationship with Peter Starr | Civil | Canon |
|---|
| Harnadek, Michael Andrew | Husband of the 2nd great-granddaughter | | |
| Harnadek, Michael Andrew II | 3rd great-grandson | V | 5 |
| Hausman, Michael | Son-in-law | | |
| Heffner | Husband of the granddaughter | | |
| Henery, Magdelena | Wife of the grandson | | |
| Hessler, Ann Elizabeth | Wife of the 3rd great-grandson | | |
| Hoffey, Sarah | Daughter-in-law | | |
| Husely | Daughter-in-law | | |
| Jr, Abraham Starr | Grandson | II | 2 |
| Jr, Donald Fred Scholl | Husband of the 4th great-granddaughter | | |
| Jr, Richard J Starr | 3rd great-grandson | V | 5 |
| Kelley, Barbara | Wife of the 2nd great-grandson | | |
| Kimmel, Bertha Mae | Wife of the great-grandson | | |
| Larkin, Ann Loretta | Wife of the 2nd great-grandson | | |
| Laubach, Amy Elizabeth | 4th great-granddaughter | VI | 6 |
| Laubach, Audrey Winifred | 3rd great-granddaughter | V | 5 |
| Laubach, Harold Levi | Husband of the 2nd great-granddaughter | | |
| Laubach, Mark Andrew | 4th great-grandson | VI | 6 |
| Laubach, Melissa Jane | 4th great-granddaughter | VI | 6 |
| Laubach, Richard Byran | 3rd great-grandson | V | 5 |
| Laubach, Sharyn Leonette | 3rd great-granddaughter | V | 5 |
| May, Dorthy Alice | Wife of the 2nd great-grandson | | |
| McDanial, Gloria | Wife of the 3rd great-grandson | | |
| Miller, Annie Elizabeath | Wife of the grandson | | |
| Miller, Sherri Lynn | Wife of the 4th great-grandson | | |
| Neuser, Elizabeth | Wife of the grandson | | |
| Overturf, Arnold A | Husband of the 2nd great-granddaughter | | |
| Overturf, Dean Danial | 3rd great-grandson | V | 5 |
| Overturf, Joslyn | 3rd great-granddaughter | V | 5 |
| Overturf, Neal Norris | 3rd great-grandson | V | 5 |
| Overturf, Reid Randal | 3rd great-grandson | V | 5 |
| Overturf, Todd Terrell | 3rd great-grandson | V | 5 |
| Panak, Mary Rose | Wife of the 2nd great-grandson | | |
| Scholl, Ryan Joseph | 5th great-grandson | VII | 7 |
| Schweickert, James Michael | Husband of the 3rd great-granddaughter | | |
| Schweickert, Mark Joseph | 4th great-grandson | VI | 6 |
| Schweickert, Patrick James | 4th great-grandson | VI | 6 |
| Scott, Norman | Husband of the 2nd great-granddaughter | | |
| Scribano, Philip | Husband of the 3rd great-granddaughter | | |
| Shadel, Celestine | Wife of the grandson | | |
| Skrincosky, Benjiman Michael | 4th great-grandson | VI | 6 |
| Skrincosky, David Michael | Husband of the 3rd great-granddaughter | | |
| Skrincosky, Mark David | 4th great-grandson | VI | 6 |
| Starr, "Hooker" | Great-grandson | III | 3 |
| Starr, Abraham | Son | I | 1 |
| Starr, Allen | Great-grandson | III | 3 |
| Starr, Arron | Great-grandson | III | 3 |
| Starr, Benjamin | Grandson | II | 2 |
| Starr, Bonnie J | 3rd great-grandson | V | 5 |
| Starr, Carolyn Geraldine | 2nd great-granddaughter | IV | 4 |